Can a Catholic Marry a Non-Catholic? Mixed Marriages Explained
Yes, a Catholic can marry a non-Catholic, and the non-Catholic does not have to convert or sign anything. Here is what the Church asks, the history, the wedding itself, and practical next steps.
If you are a Catholic engaged to someone who is not Catholic, or a non-Catholic engaged to a Catholic, you may be anxious. Perhaps you have heard that the non-Catholic partner will have to convert, or sign a promise to raise the children Catholic, or that the Church will refuse to marry you at all. Perhaps an older relative remembers bitter stories from the past. The reality today is much more welcoming. A Catholic can marry a non-Catholic, with the bishop’s permission, which is routinely given. The non-Catholic partner does not have to convert or sign anything. This article explains what the Church allows and asks, why, the Bible’s teaching on mixed households, the Church’s longstanding caution, the Catholic partner’s promise, the painful history, the wedding itself, the question of Communion, inspiring stories of mixed marriages, and how to begin.

1. Yes, with the bishop’s permission
A Catholic may marry a non-Catholic. If the other partner is a baptised Christian, such as an Anglican, Lutheran, Methodist, Baptist or Orthodox Christian, the Catholic needs the “express permission” of the bishop (Code of Canon Law, canon 1124). If the other partner has never been baptised, for example a Jew, a Muslim, a Hindu, a Buddhist or someone with no religion, the Catholic needs a “dispensation” from the bishop, without which the marriage would not be valid in the Church’s eyes (canon 1086). In practice, both are routinely granted, usually through the parish priest.
The rules were greatly simplified after the Second Vatican Council. On 31 March 1970, Pope Paul VI issued an apostolic letter, Matrimonia mixta, which relaxed the old requirements, recognised the conscience of the non-Catholic partner, and gave local bishops the authority to grant permissions and dispensations without referring to Rome.
Mixed marriages have been part of Christian life from the beginning. One of the most famous Christian women of the ancient world, St Monica, was married to a pagan, Patricius, a man of quick temper and frequent infidelity. She won him over through patience and kindness, and he was baptised shortly before his death around 371. Their son was St Augustine, one of the greatest theologians in Christian history (Augustine, Confessions 9.9).
2. A true marriage, and often a sacrament
The Catholic Church teaches that a marriage between a Catholic and another baptised Christian is a true sacrament. A marriage between a Catholic and an unbaptised person is not a sacrament in the technical sense, but it is a valid, true and honoured marriage, a lifelong bond.
St Paul describes the love of husband and wife as a sign of Christ’s love for the Church: “Husbands, love your wives, as Christ also loved the church, and delivered himself up for it… This is a great sacrament; but I speak in Christ and in the church” (Ephesians 5:25, 32). Catholics believe that when two baptised people marry, their marriage becomes a sacrament, a sign and means of Christ’s grace.
The Church formally listed marriage among the seven sacraments at the Council of Florence. In its Decree for the Armenians in 1439, it described marriage as “a sign of the union of Christ and the Church”.
The Church recognised the validity of marriages between Catholics and Protestants even centuries ago. In the Netherlands in the eighteenth century, many Catholics married Protestants before Protestant ministers or civil officials, because Catholic priests were restricted. In 1741, Pope Benedict XIV issued a declaration, Matrimonia quae in locis, ruling that such marriages were valid even though no Catholic priest was present. This “Benedictine declaration” protected many families.
3. The Bible on mixed households
Scripture shows mixed households bearing good fruit, and St Paul specifically tells believers to stay with unbelieving spouses who are willing to live with them in peace.
Some early Christians, converted after marriage, wondered whether they should leave their unbelieving husbands or wives. Paul answered: “If any brother hath a wife that believeth not, and she consent to dwell with him, let him not put her away. And if any woman hath a husband that believeth not, and he consent to dwell with her, let her not put away her husband. For the unbelieving husband is sanctified by the believing wife; and the unbelieving wife is sanctified by the believing husband: otherwise your children should be unclean; but now they are holy” (1 Corinthians 7:12-14).
Paul’s closest co-worker grew up in a mixed household. Timothy was the son of “a Jewish woman that believed” and a father who was “a Gentile” (Acts 16:1). Paul praised “the faith… which dwelt first in thy grandmother Lois, and in thy mother Eunice” (2 Timothy 1:5). Timothy’s faith came from his mother and grandmother, even though his father did not share it.
One of the most beautiful books of the Old Testament tells of a marriage across a religious and national divide. Ruth was a Moabite, a foreigner from a people Israel regarded with suspicion. After her Israelite husband died, she refused to leave her mother-in-law Naomi, saying: “thy people shall be my people, and thy God my God.” She married Boaz of Bethlehem, and their great-grandson was King David (Ruth 4:13-17). Matthew names her in the genealogy of Jesus (Matthew 1:5).
4. Why the Church is cautious
At the same time, the Church’s caution about mixed marriages is old and comes from long experience: differences of faith can strain a marriage, and can weaken the faith of the believing partner and the children.
The Old Testament gives a sobering example. King Solomon, the wisest of kings, married many foreign wives. “And when he was now old, his heart was turned away by women to follow strange gods”, and he built shrines for their gods on the hill outside Jerusalem (1 Kings 11:4-8). His marriages contributed to the division of his kingdom.
After the Babylonian exile, the scribe Ezra was alarmed to find that many Jewish men who had returned to Jerusalem had married women from the surrounding peoples. He saw these marriages as a threat to the survival of Israel’s faith, and demanded, very harshly, that they be ended (Ezra 9-10). The Church does not follow Ezra’s harsh remedy, but it understands his concern.
The early Church was cautious too. In the early fourth century, a council of bishops at Elvira in Spain forbade Christian parents to give their daughters in marriage to pagans, Jews or heretics, fearing that the daughters would lose their faith (canons 15-16). The Church’s rules have changed greatly since, but the underlying concern, to help couples protect and share their faith, remains.
5. Only the Catholic makes a promise
Many people believe that the non-Catholic partner must promise to raise the children Catholic. This is no longer true. Only the Catholic partner makes a promise.
Church law today requires the Catholic party to “declare that he or she is prepared to remove dangers of defecting from the faith and is to make a sincere promise to do all in his or her power so that all offspring are baptised and brought up in the Catholic Church.” The other party is simply to be “informed at an appropriate time” of this promise, so that he or she is aware of it (canon 1125). The non-Catholic partner is not asked to promise or sign anything.
The earlier law was much stricter. The 1917 Code of Canon Law required guarantees from both spouses, usually in writing, that the Catholic party would be free to practise the faith and that all the children would be baptised and raised Catholic (canon 1061). Many older couples remember signing these promises, and some found them painful.
The Church now recognises that the non-Catholic partner may feel a similar duty in conscience towards his or her own faith. The Vatican’s Directory for the Application of Principles and Norms on Ecumenism (1993) acknowledges that the non-Catholic partner may have a similar obligation, and asks that the decision about the children’s baptism and religious upbringing be made by both parents together, respecting each other’s conscience (paragraphs 150-151). The Catholic promises to do “all in his or her power”, which does not mean forcing the other spouse.
6. A painful history
The objection that the Church’s rules on mixed marriages have hurt families is fair, and the Church accepts that some of its past practice did.
In 1907, Pope Pius X issued a decree called Ne Temere, which came into force at Easter 1908. It required all Catholics, everywhere, to marry before a Catholic priest for their marriage to be valid. In Ireland, this led to a notorious case. In 1910, in Belfast, a Catholic man named Alexander McCann, who had married a Presbyterian woman, Agnes, in a Presbyterian church, reportedly told by his priest that their marriage was not valid, left her and took their two children. Agnes never saw them again. The case caused an uproar among Ulster Protestants, who saw it as proof of what “Rome rule” would mean.
In 1957, in the small village of Fethard-on-Sea in County Wexford, Ireland, a Protestant woman named Sheila Cloney, married to a Catholic farmer, refused to send her daughters to the Catholic school, as the Catholic promise required. She left with the children. Local Catholics, encouraged by their priest, organised a boycott of Protestant-owned shops and businesses in the village. In 1998, Bishop Brendan Comiskey of Ferns publicly apologised for the boycott on behalf of the Catholic Church.
The Church today strongly insists on respect for conscience. In 1981, Pope John Paul II wrote that religious freedom must be respected in mixed marriages, and that it could be violated “by undue pressure to make the partner change his or her beliefs” (Familiaris Consortio 78).
7. The wedding itself
A mixed marriage normally takes place before a Catholic priest or deacon and two witnesses, usually in a Catholic church. But the bishop can allow another form, for example in the non-Catholic partner’s church, led by his or her minister.
The requirement of a priest and witnesses goes back to the Council of Trent. Before then, many couples married in secret, simply by exchanging vows privately, and one partner could later deny that the marriage had ever happened. In 1563 the council’s decree Tametsi required marriages to be celebrated before the parish priest and two or three witnesses, to protect people, especially women, from such abuses. As we have seen, Pius X’s decree Ne Temere of 1907 extended this requirement to all Catholics everywhere, including those marrying other Christians.
Today a bishop can grant a “dispensation from canonical form”, allowing the wedding to take place in another church, before a minister of another Christian community, or even in a civil ceremony, for a good reason, such as family harmony or the religious convictions of the other partner (canon 1127). What is not allowed is a “double ceremony”, with two separate religious weddings, one Catholic and one non-Catholic, in which vows are exchanged twice. A Catholic priest may, however, take part in a wedding in another church, offering prayers and readings, and the other minister may take part in a Catholic wedding.
8. Conversion not required; Communion limited
The non-Catholic partner is never required to convert. Many never do; some, freely, decide to become Catholic years later. But one real difficulty is that Holy Communion cannot normally be shared, which many couples find painful.
When a Catholic marries a baptised non-Catholic, the Church’s marriage rite suggests that the wedding usually be celebrated outside of Mass, with a Liturgy of the Word, so that the congregation, often with many non-Catholic guests, is not divided at Communion (Order of Celebrating Matrimony 36). A Mass can be celebrated with the bishop’s permission, but the non-Catholic partner and guests would not ordinarily receive Communion.
On 15 November 2015, Pope Francis visited the Lutheran church in Rome. A Lutheran woman named Anke de Bernardinis, married to a Catholic, asked him what she and her husband could do to receive Communion together. The Pope did not give permission, but spoke movingly about their shared baptism and their shared life, and suggested that she pray and follow her conscience. His careful answer was widely discussed.
In 2018 the German bishops prepared guidance that would have allowed Protestant spouses of Catholics, in individual cases, to receive Communion. On 25 May 2018, Archbishop Luis Ladaria, prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, wrote on the Pope’s behalf that the document was not mature enough to be published. The question remains under discussion. See Which Sacraments Can I Receive If I’m Not Catholic?
9. Patient witness
Many mixed marriages have been places of patient witness to faith, and some have even changed history, without any forcing of conscience.
In the late fifth century, Clotilde, a Catholic princess of Burgundy, married Clovis, the pagan king of the Franks. According to St Gregory of Tours, she prayed for him and urged him to believe for years. In a desperate battle, Clovis prayed to “the God of Clotilde” for victory, and promised to be baptised if he won. He won, and around 496 he was baptised by St Remigius, bishop of Reims, with thousands of his warriors (History of the Franks 2.29-31). France was born a Catholic kingdom.
A century later, Bertha, a Christian princess from the Frankish royal family, married Æthelberht, the pagan king of Kent in England. She brought her own bishop with her and worshipped in a small church outside Canterbury. When Pope Gregory the Great sent the monk Augustine to England in 597, Bertha’s influence helped ensure that he was welcomed, and Æthelberht was baptised (Bede, Ecclesiastical History 1.25-26).
In the twentieth century, Elisabeth Leseur, a Catholic woman in Paris, was married to Félix Leseur, a doctor and editor who was a committed atheist and often mocked her faith. Elisabeth never argued with him; she loved him, prayed for him and offered her sufferings for him, writing her spiritual reflections in a private journal. She died of cancer in 1914. When Félix read her journal, he was overwhelmed. He returned to the Catholic faith, became a Dominican, and was ordained a priest in 1923. He spent the rest of his life making her writings known.
10. See a priest together, early
The best next step is for both of you to see a priest together, early in your engagement. Be honest about your differences, and prepare for marriage as a couple.
The Book of Tobit describes a beautiful beginning to a marriage. On their wedding night, Tobias said to his bride Sarah, “Sarah, arise, and let us pray to God.” Together they prayed, asking God to have mercy on them and to let them grow old together (Tobit 8:4-8). Many couples of different traditions find that praying together, in simple words they both share, is a strong foundation.
Jesus himself blessed marriage by his presence. He accepted an invitation to a village wedding at Cana in Galilee, and at his mother’s request turned water into wine when the wine ran out. John tells us it was “the beginning of miracles” (John 2:1-11).
Couples in mixed marriages need not face their questions alone. In 1968, Ruth Reardon, a Catholic, and her husband Martin, an Anglican, founded the Association of Interchurch Families in England, so that couples like themselves could support one another, share their experiences and work for greater understanding between the churches. Similar groups now exist in many countries. Many Catholic parishes also offer marriage preparation courses designed with mixed couples in mind.
Frequently asked questions
Does my non-Catholic fiancé(e) have to become Catholic? No. Conversion is never required for marriage.
Does the non-Catholic have to promise to raise the children Catholic? No. Only the Catholic partner makes a promise, to do all in his or her power. The decision is made together.
Can we marry in a non-Catholic church? Yes, with a dispensation from the bishop. Ask your priest early.
Is our marriage a sacrament? If both of you are baptised Christians, yes. If one is not baptised, it is a true and valid marriage, though not a sacrament in the technical sense.
You may also like My Spouse Threatens Divorce If I Become Catholic and Do We Need a New Civil Marriage Licence for a Catholic Convalidation?
Sources and further reading
- The Bible: Ruth 4:13-17; 1 Kings 11:1-8; Ezra 9-10; Tobit 8:4-8; Matthew 1:5; John 2:1-11; Acts 16:1-3; 1 Corinthians 7:12-16; Ephesians 5:25-32; 2 Timothy 1:5.
- Catechism of the Catholic Church, 1633-1637.
- Code of Canon Law (1983), canons 1086, 1124-1129; Code of Canon Law (1917), canon 1061.
- Paul VI, Matrimonia mixta (1970); John Paul II, Familiaris Consortio 78 (1981); Pontifical Council for Promoting Christian Unity, Directory for Ecumenism 143-160 (1993); Order of Celebrating Matrimony (2nd ed.).
- Council of Elvira (c. 305), canons 15-16; Council of Florence, Decree for the Armenians (1439); Council of Trent, Tametsi (1563); Benedict XIV, Matrimonia quae in locis (1741); Pius X, Ne Temere (1907).
- St Augustine, Confessions 9.9; St Gregory of Tours, History of the Franks 2.29-31; Bede, Ecclesiastical History 1.25-26.
- Elisabeth Leseur, My Spirit Rejoices: The Diary of a Christian Soul in an Age of Unbelief.
- Association of Interchurch Families (England and Wales).

