Roman Catholic vs Catholic: Is There a Difference? Eastern Catholics Explained
“Roman Catholic” and “Catholic” usually mean the same Church, but strictly the Catholic Church includes 23 Eastern Catholic Churches too. Here is what that means and why it matters.
You may have met the question on a hospital form or a census: “Religion: Roman Catholic”. Or perhaps you have a friend who says she is Maronite Catholic, Ukrainian Catholic or Syro-Malabar Catholic, and insists she is “Catholic but not Roman Catholic”. Are these different churches? Is a Roman Catholic different from a Catholic? The short answer is that there is no difference in faith. In everyday English “Roman Catholic” is used to mean the whole Catholic Church. Strictly speaking, though, it names only the largest part of it, the Latin or Roman Church. The Catholic Church is in fact a communion of twenty-four churches: the Latin Church and twenty-three Eastern Catholic Churches, all sharing one faith and all in communion with the Pope. This article explains how that works and why it matters.

1. One faith, many churches
From its very first day, the Church spoke many languages. At Pentecost, Luke tells us, Jews from “every nation under heaven” were gathered in Jerusalem: Parthians, Medes, Elamites, people from Mesopotamia, Egypt, Libya, Rome, Crete and Arabia. When the apostles began to speak, “every man heard them speak in his own tongue” (Acts 2:5-11). One Gospel, one Spirit, many languages and cultures.
That variety continued. As Christianity spread, different regions developed their own ways of celebrating the liturgy, their own customs and their own church law. The great centres of the ancient Church, Rome, Alexandria, Antioch, Jerusalem and Constantinople, each gave birth to distinct traditions. Most of the Christians who still follow those Eastern traditions are Orthodox, but a significant number are Catholic, in full communion with the Pope.
The Catholic Church teaches that these churches are fully equal. The Second Vatican Council declared in 1964 that the Eastern and Western churches within the Catholic communion “are of equal dignity, so that none of them is superior to the others as regards rite” (Orientalium Ecclesiarum 3). Being Eastern does not make someone a second-class Catholic.
The Vatican’s yearbook, the Annuario Pontificio, lists twenty-three Eastern Catholic Churches alongside the Latin Church, with around eighteen million members between them. The largest are the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church and the Syro-Malabar Church of India; others include the Maronites of Lebanon, the Melkites of Syria and Lebanon, the Chaldeans of Iraq, the Coptic Catholics of Egypt, the Ethiopian, Armenian, Romanian, Ruthenian and Syro-Malankara Catholic Churches, and several more.
2. The Church calls itself simply “Catholic”
It may surprise you to learn that the Church does not usually call itself “Roman Catholic” at all. In its official documents it normally says simply “the Catholic Church”.
The clearest example is the Church’s official summary of its teaching, promulgated by Pope John Paul II in 1992. It is called the Catechism of the Catholic Church, not the Catechism of the Roman Catholic Church. The same is true of the Second Vatican Council’s documents, which speak of “the Catholic Church” throughout.
At the First Vatican Council in 1870, a draft document began with the words “the Roman Catholic Church”. Several bishops, especially from English-speaking countries, objected. They pointed out that in England “Roman Catholic” was used by Anglicans to suggest that the Roman Church was only one branch of a wider Catholic Church that included the Church of England. The wording was changed to “the Holy Catholic Apostolic Roman Church” (Dei Filius), which makes clear that “Roman” describes the one Catholic Church, not a branch of it.
In English, “Roman Catholic” became common after the Reformation, especially in Britain, where the Church of England claimed to be part of the “Catholic” Church too. British law used the term officially. The great act of Parliament that in 1829 restored most civil rights to Catholics in Britain and Ireland, allowing them to sit in Parliament for the first time since the seventeenth century, was called the Roman Catholic Relief Act. Over time Catholics themselves adopted the term, and it is widely used today without any negative meaning.
3. Why “Roman”?
The word “Roman” points to communion with the Bishop of Rome, the Pope. Catholics believe that the bishop of Rome is the successor of St Peter, who, with St Paul, preached and was martyred in Rome.
Rome’s importance in the Church goes back to the New Testament. St Paul’s longest and most important letter was written to the Christians of Rome. He opened it by thanking God that “your faith is spoken of in the whole world” (Romans 1:8). Paul had not yet visited Rome, but its church was already famous.
Around 180, St Irenaeus of Lyons, wanting to show where true Christian teaching could be found, pointed to the church of Rome, “the very great, the very ancient and universally known Church founded and organised at Rome by the two most glorious apostles, Peter and Paul”. He added that every church should agree with this church because of its pre-eminent authority (Against Heresies 3.3.2).
Archaeology supports the ancient tradition that Peter was buried in Rome. Between 1940 and 1949, on the orders of Pope Pius XII, archaeologists excavated beneath St Peter’s Basilica. They found a Roman cemetery from the first and second centuries, and directly under the high altar a small second-century shrine built over a simple grave. In his Christmas message of 1950, Pius XII announced that the tomb of the Prince of the Apostles had been found. Scholars still debate the details, but the shrine shows that by around AD 160 Christians were honouring this spot as Peter’s grave. To be “Roman” Catholic is to be in communion with the bishop who sits on that grave.
4. Fully Catholic, but not “Roman”
The Eastern Catholic Churches are fully Catholic. They believe everything the Catholic Church teaches, accept the authority of the Pope, and share Communion with Latin Catholics. But they are not “Roman” in the sense of following the Roman rite. They have their own liturgies, their own spiritual traditions, their own law and their own bishops, many of them led by a patriarch or major archbishop.
The Maronite Church of Lebanon traces its origins to St Maron, a hermit who lived on a mountain in Syria and died around 410. His disciples founded a monastery that became the centre of a community, and the Maronites moved into the mountains of Lebanon. Maronites hold that they never broke communion with Rome. Historians debate this: the chronicler William of Tyre, writing during the Crusades, says they entered union with the Latin Church in 1182. Either way, they have been in full communion ever since. Lebanese Maronites have spread across the world, and the patriarch, who lives at Bkerké above Beirut, is an important figure in Lebanese national life.
The Syro-Malabar Church of Kerala, in southern India, traces its origin, according to a very ancient tradition, to the preaching of the Apostle Thomas, who is said to have landed on the Malabar coast in AD 52. The “Thomas Christians” used the East Syriac liturgy, inherited from the Church of the East in Mesopotamia. Today the Syro-Malabar Church has over four million members and is one of the most vibrant churches in the world, sending priests and religious sisters across the globe.
Because the Eastern Churches have their own traditions, they also have their own law. In 1983 Pope John Paul II issued the Code of Canon Law for the Latin Church. On 18 October 1990 he issued a separate code, the Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches, for the Eastern Catholic Churches. The Pope is the supreme legislator for both, but they are distinct bodies of law.
5. Where Eastern Catholic Churches came from
Most Eastern Catholic Churches came into being when groups of Eastern Christians, previously Orthodox or Oriental Orthodox, restored communion with Rome while keeping their own liturgy and customs. This history is still sensitive for the Orthodox, who sometimes see these churches as the fruit of Catholic poaching.
The most important example is the Union of Brest of 1595-1596. Orthodox bishops of the Kyivan church, then living in the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth, decided to enter into union with Rome while keeping their Byzantine liturgy, their married clergy and their own calendar. Their descendants are today’s Ukrainian Greek Catholics and Belarusian Greek Catholics. Many Orthodox at the time, and since, saw the union as a betrayal encouraged by the Catholic Polish state.
Another example is the Melkite Greek Catholic Church. In 1724, a disputed election in the ancient Patriarchate of Antioch produced two rival patriarchs, one favouring union with Rome and one opposed. The result was two lines of patriarchs: one Greek Orthodox, and one Melkite Catholic, which Rome recognised in 1729.
Catholics and Orthodox have tried to address these tensions honestly. In 1993, the official joint theological commission meeting at Balamand in Lebanon issued a declaration rejecting “uniatism”, the method of seeking unity by drawing groups away from the Orthodox Church, as a model for the future. At the same time, it affirmed that the existing Eastern Catholic Churches have the right to exist and to serve their faithful.
6. A history of costly faithfulness
Eastern Catholics have paid heavily for their loyalty to both their Eastern traditions and their communion with Rome, especially under communist rule.
In March 1946, Soviet authorities staged a “synod” in Lviv, in western Ukraine, without any Ukrainian Greek Catholic bishops present, since all of them had been arrested. The pseudo-synod declared the union with Rome dissolved and handed the church’s property to the Russian Orthodox Church. For more than forty years the Ukrainian Greek Catholic Church existed only underground, with priests ordained in secret and liturgies celebrated in forests and private apartments. It was legalised again only in December 1989, as the Soviet Union was collapsing.
Its leader, Metropolitan Josyf Slipyj, was arrested in April 1945. He spent the next eighteen years in Soviet prisons and labour camps, including in Siberia, refusing repeated demands to renounce communion with Rome. In 1963, after appeals by Pope John XXIII and US President John F. Kennedy, he was released and allowed to go to Rome, where he arrived just in time to take part in the Second Vatican Council. He was later made a cardinal.
In Romania, the communist government outlawed the Greek Catholic Church in 1948 and forced it into the Romanian Orthodox Church. All its bishops were arrested. Seven of them died in prison or under house arrest rather than abandon their communion with Rome. On 2 June 2019, on the Field of Liberty at Blaj in Transylvania, Pope Francis beatified all seven as martyrs.
7. Eastern customs inside the Catholic Church
Eastern Catholics keep the customs of their own traditions, which can surprise Latin Catholics.
Most notably, Eastern Catholic Churches ordain married men as priests, as the Orthodox do. Many parish priests in Ukraine, Lebanon and Romania are married with families. Some Eastern Catholic Churches, such as the Syro-Malabar Church of India, keep priestly celibacy as the Latin Church does. This is an ancient practice that goes back to the apostles: St Peter himself was married, since Jesus healed his mother-in-law of a fever (Mark 1:30-31), and Paul mentions that Peter travelled, apparently with his wife, on his missionary journeys (1 Corinthians 9:5).
Most Eastern Catholics also give infants Confirmation (often called Chrismation) at the same time as baptism, and those of the Byzantine tradition give infants Communion as well and use leavened bread in the Eucharist; some follow the Julian calendar. Practice varies: Maronite and Armenian Catholics, for example, use unleavened bread. These differences were formally accepted at the Council of Florence in 1439, which declared that the body of Christ is truly consecrated in both wheat bread, whether leavened or unleavened, and that priests should consecrate according to the custom of their own church (Laetentur Caeli).
Not every Catholic leader has respected these customs. In 1889, a widowed Eastern Catholic priest named Alexis Toth arrived in Minneapolis to serve immigrants from Carpathian Ruthenia. When he presented himself to the local Latin archbishop, John Ireland, the archbishop refused to recognise him, partly because Eastern priests had been married, and forbade him to minister. Toth and his parish turned to the Russian Orthodox Church, and over the following years tens of thousands of Eastern Catholics in America followed. Toth is today a canonised Orthodox saint. Rome’s ban on married Eastern Catholic priests ministering in North America and other “Latin” territories was finally lifted in 2014.
8. Who else calls itself “catholic”?
The word “catholic” is not used only by the Catholic Church. Many Christians confess in the Nicene Creed, drawn up in 381, that they believe in “one, holy, catholic and apostolic Church”. Orthodox, Anglicans, Lutherans, Methodists and others say these words, and they mean them.
In nineteenth-century England, leaders of the Oxford Movement, such as John Keble and Edward Pusey, argued in their Tracts for the Times (1833-1841) that the Church of England was one of three “branches” of the one Catholic Church, together with Rome and the Orthodox. Anglo-Catholics still hold this view, and it is the reason why English Catholics were often wary of accepting the label “Roman”.
Catholics understand “catholic” to include visible communion with the successor of Peter. St Augustine, writing around 397, made an interesting observation about how even rival groups recognised the name. If a stranger arrives in a city and asks where “the Catholic church” meets, he said, no heretic would dare to point to his own meeting place (Against the Letter of Mani Called “The Foundation” 4). The name “Catholic” belonged, by common recognition, to the great Church in communion with the apostolic sees.
9. Catholic does not mean Latin
One of the most important lessons of Eastern Catholic history is that “Catholic” does not mean “Latin”. Rome has sometimes made the mistake of pressing Latin customs on Eastern Christians, and has since recognised the error.
The apostles themselves set the principle. When Gentiles began to join the Church, the question arose whether they must adopt Jewish customs. The council at Jerusalem decided to lay on them “no further burden” than a few necessary things (Acts 15:28). The faith could be lived in a new culture without forcing everyone into the old one.
That principle was not always kept. In 1599, at the Synod of Diamper in Kerala, the Portuguese Archbishop of Goa, Aleixo de Menezes, imposed many Latin practices on the ancient Thomas Christians of India, burned some of their Syriac books, and cut them off from their traditional bishops in Mesopotamia. Resentment built up for decades. In 1653, thousands of Thomas Christians gathered at a stone cross at Mattancherry, held ropes tied to it, and swore the “Coonan Cross Oath” that they would no longer submit to the Portuguese Jesuits. Many of them eventually broke away; their descendants include several of today’s Orthodox and other churches in Kerala.
In 1894, Pope Leo XIII issued an apostolic letter, Orientalium Dignitas, defending the dignity of the Eastern rites. He forbade Latin missionaries to persuade Eastern Christians to adopt the Latin rite, on pain of suspension from their office. Since then, and especially since the Second Vatican Council, Rome has encouraged Eastern Catholics to recover their own traditions.
10. Visit an Eastern Catholic liturgy
The best way to discover how wide the word “Catholic” really is would be to visit an Eastern Catholic liturgy. Many cities have a Ukrainian, Maronite, Melkite, Syro-Malabar, Chaldean or Ruthenian parish.
Any Catholic may attend and receive Communion at an Eastern Catholic liturgy. Church law states that the Sunday obligation is satisfied by attending Mass “in a Catholic rite” anywhere (canon 1248 §1), and that the faithful may receive Communion in any Catholic rite (canon 923). A Latin Catholic who goes to a Byzantine Divine Liturgy on Sunday has fully kept the Sunday.
In the Book of Revelation, John saw “a great multitude, which no man could number, of all nations, and tribes, and peoples, and tongues, standing before the throne, and in sight of the Lamb” (Revelation 7:9). The Eastern Catholic Churches give a glimpse of that picture on earth.
The Church’s history offers a lovely example of unity in diversity. In the ninth century two brothers from Thessalonica, Sts Cyril and Methodius, went as missionaries to the Slavs of Moravia. They created an alphabet for the Slavonic language and translated the Gospels and the liturgy into it. German clergy objected that worship should be only in Latin, Greek or Hebrew. In 868 the brothers went to Rome, and Pope Adrian II approved the Slavonic liturgy, placing their books on the altar of a Roman church. In 1980 Pope John Paul II named Cyril and Methodius co-patrons of Europe, alongside St Benedict, the father of Western monasticism. Catholic, they showed, has always been bigger than Roman.
Frequently asked questions
Is “Roman Catholic” wrong? No. It is widely used and not offensive, but “Catholic” is the Church’s own usual name for itself.
Are Eastern Catholics the same as Orthodox? No. They share Eastern liturgies and customs with the Orthodox, but they are in full communion with the Pope. See Catholic vs Orthodox.
Can a Latin Catholic receive Communion at a Byzantine or Maronite liturgy? Yes. All Catholic rites are open to all Catholics.
What should I put on a form? “Catholic” is enough; “Roman Catholic” is also fine if you belong to the Latin Church. Eastern Catholics may prefer to name their own church.
You may also like Are Catholics Christian? and Can the Pope Wear Ordinary Clothes?
Sources and further reading
- The Bible: Mark 1:30-31; Acts 2:5-11; 15:28-29; Romans 1:7-8; 1 Corinthians 9:5; Revelation 7:9.
- Second Vatican Council, Orientalium Ecclesiarum (1964).
- First Vatican Council, Dei Filius (1870).
- Code of Canon Law (1983), canons 923 and 1248; Code of Canons of the Eastern Churches (1990).
- Council of Florence, Laetentur Caeli (1439); Leo XIII, Orientalium Dignitas (1894).
- Joint International Commission for Theological Dialogue, Balamand Declaration (1993).
- St Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.3.2; St Augustine, Against the Letter of Mani Called “The Foundation” 4.
- Annuario Pontificio (Vatican yearbook), section on the Eastern Catholic Churches.
- Ronald Roberson, The Eastern Christian Churches: A Brief Survey (CNEWA).
- Margherita Guarducci and others on the Vatican excavations; John Evangelist Walsh, The Bones of St Peter (1982).

