Who Founded the Catholic Church, and Is It the Oldest Christian Church?

Did Constantine or the medieval popes invent Catholicism? Here is what the evidence says about where the Catholic Church comes from, and an honest answer on whether it is the oldest.

Catholics believe that the Catholic Church was founded by Jesus Christ himself, on his apostles, around the year 30, and that the Catholic Church of today is the same community, grown from that seed over two thousand years. You may have heard other claims: that the Catholic Church was invented by the Emperor Constantine in the fourth century, or by medieval popes, or that the “real” Church went underground and Catholicism is a later corruption. This article looks at the evidence: what the New Testament says, what the earliest Christian writers after the apostles describe, how Rome came to have its place, and whether the Catholic Church can honestly claim to be the oldest Christian church. It also faces squarely the dark chapters of the Church’s history.

Early Christian wall painting of the Good Shepherd carrying a sheep on his shoulders, from the Roman catacombs
The Good Shepherd, one of the earliest Christian images, painted on a wall of the Roman catacombs in the third century, long before Constantine. Reproduction from Joseph Wilpert's 1903 survey of catacomb paintings. Image: unknown artist, Rome, 3rd century A.D. / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain

1. What Catholics believe

Catholics believe that Jesus deliberately founded a Church: not just a set of ideas, but a community with leaders, rites and a mission. The Gospels describe how he chose a particular group of men to lead it. Mark tells us that Jesus “going up into a mountain, called unto him whom he would himself… And he made that twelve should be with him, and that he might send them to preach” (Mark 3:13-14).

After his death and resurrection, the Church went public. On the Jewish feast of Pentecost, the Holy Spirit came upon the disciples gathered in Jerusalem. Peter stood up and preached to the crowds, and Luke records that “there were added in that day about three thousand souls” (Acts 2:41). Christians have often called Pentecost the birthday of the Church.

The Catholic Church claims to be that same Church, continuing through history. The Second Vatican Council expressed this carefully in 1964: the one Church of Christ “subsists in the Catholic Church, which is governed by the successor of Peter and by the bishops in communion with him”. But it immediately added that “many elements of sanctification and of truth are found outside its visible structure” (Lumen Gentium 8). The Catholic claim is strong, but it is not a claim that there is nothing of Christ anywhere else.

2. Constantine did not found the Church

One of the most common claims is that the Catholic Church was founded by the Emperor Constantine, who legalised Christianity in 313. The historical evidence shows clearly that the Church had bishops, the Eucharist and the name “Catholic” long before Constantine was born, around 272.

Around the year 107, nearly two centuries before Constantine, St Ignatius, bishop of Antioch, was taken in chains to Rome to die in the arena. On the way he wrote letters to churches in Asia Minor and to Rome. They describe churches led in each city by a single bishop, with a council of presbyters (priests) and deacons. They insist that the Eucharist is the flesh of Jesus Christ. And Ignatius is the first writer known to use the phrase “the Catholic Church” (Letter to the Smyrnaeans 8).

In 304, during the last and worst persecution under the Emperor Diocletian, forty-nine Christians in the town of Abitinae in North Africa, including a priest, children and whole families, were arrested for gathering to celebrate the Sunday Eucharist, which the emperor had forbidden. Brought before the Roman proconsul in Carthage and asked why they had disobeyed, they answered: “Without the Lord’s Day we cannot live.” They died under torture or in prison. This was nine years before Constantine’s edict.

What Constantine did was to stop the persecution. In 313, he and his fellow emperor Licinius granted freedom of worship to Christians and everyone else in the so-called Edict of Milan. Christianity did not become the official religion of the Roman Empire until 380, when the Emperor Theodosius issued the Edict of Thessalonica, more than four decades after Constantine’s death. Constantine helped the Church; he did not invent it.

3. Jesus formed a lasting community

Some people imagine that Jesus came only to teach a spiritual message, and that the structures of the Church were invented later. But the Gospels show Jesus deliberately preparing a community that would last after he was gone, with authority, rites and a mission to the whole world.

After his resurrection, Jesus met the eleven remaining apostles on a mountain in Galilee and gave them their commission: “Going therefore, teach ye all nations; baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost. Teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you: and behold I am with you all days, even to the consummation of the world” (Matthew 28:19-20). Jesus promised to be with his Church until the end of time, which implies it would still exist.

John’s Gospel ends with a moving scene by the Sea of Galilee. After breakfast on the shore, Jesus asked Peter three times, “Lovest thou me?”, matching Peter’s three denials. Each time Peter said yes, and each time Jesus gave him a charge: “Feed my lambs… Feed my sheep” (John 21:15-17). Peter was given a pastoral responsibility for Christ’s flock.

A very early Christian handbook called the Didache (“The Teaching”), probably written in the late first or early second century, shows the result. It gives instructions on how to baptise (in running water if possible, in the name of the Trinity), on fasting on Wednesdays and Fridays, on celebrating the Eucharist on the Lord’s Day, and on choosing “bishops and deacons worthy of the Lord”. Within a generation or two of the apostles, the Church already had a recognisable shape.

4. Apostolic succession

Catholics believe that the apostles appointed successors, and those successors appointed others in turn, in an unbroken chain down to the bishops of today. This is called apostolic succession.

The New Testament shows the process beginning. After Judas betrayed Jesus and died, Peter stood up among the believers and said that someone must take his place: “his bishopric let another take”. They prayed, cast lots, and Matthias was chosen to be numbered with the eleven apostles (Acts 1:15-26). The office continued even when the person changed.

St Paul did the same. He left his companion Titus in Crete with instructions to “ordain priests in every city” (Titus 1:5). And he told Timothy, “the things which thou hast heard of me by many witnesses, the same commend to faithful men, who shall be fit to teach others also” (2 Timothy 2:2). That one sentence describes four generations: Paul, Timothy, faithful men, and others.

Around the year 96, the church of Rome sent a letter to the church in Corinth, where some younger members had deposed their leaders. The letter, traditionally attributed to St Clement, the third successor of Peter, explained that the apostles had appointed bishops and deacons, and had “added the further provision that, if they should fall asleep, other approved men should succeed to their ministry” (1 Clement 44). The church of Rome was already intervening in another church’s affairs, appealing to the principle of succession.

5. Rome, Peter and Paul

Why is the Catholic Church centred on Rome? Catholics believe it is because both Peter and Paul preached and were martyred there, and the bishops of Rome are Peter’s successors. (The biblical basis in Jesus’s words to Peter in Matthew 16 is explained in our separate article, Why Did Jesus Call Peter a Rock?)

The New Testament itself places Peter in Rome. His first letter ends with greetings from “the church that is in Babylon” (1 Peter 5:13). “Babylon” was a common code name among early Christians and Jews for Rome, the great pagan capital, as it is in the Book of Revelation.

Around the year 200, a Roman churchman named Gaius was arguing with a member of a sect who boasted about the tombs of apostles in Asia Minor. Gaius replied that he could show his opponent the “trophies” (the shrines or tombs) of the apostles who founded the Roman church: “if you go to the Vatican or the Ostian Way, you will find the trophies of those who founded this church.” His words are quoted by Eusebius (Church History 2.25). The modern excavations under St Peter’s Basilica found a second-century shrine exactly where Gaius said it would be.

Around 180, St Irenaeus of Lyons listed the bishops of Rome in order: after Peter and Paul came Linus, then Anacletus, then Clement, then Evaristus, Alexander, Sixtus, Telesphorus (“who was gloriously martyred”), Hyginus, Pius, Anicetus, Soter and, in Irenaeus’s own day, Eleutherius, “the twelfth from the apostles” (Against Heresies 3.3.3). The present Pope, Leo XIV, stands in that same line.

6. Is it the oldest? An honest answer

Is the Catholic Church the oldest Christian church? Catholics believe that it is the original Church founded by Christ. But honesty requires saying that the Orthodox churches and other ancient Eastern churches make exactly the same claim, and their claim to unbroken continuity from the apostles is also serious.

The Gospel did not begin in Rome. The first Christian community was in Jerusalem, and the first great Gentile church was in Antioch, where the disciples were first called Christians (Acts 2:41-47; 11:19-26). The churches of Jerusalem, Antioch and Alexandria all have apostolic roots, and their bishops today are Orthodox (and in some cases also Catholic or Oriental Orthodox).

Armenia was the first kingdom to make Christianity its official religion, traditionally in 301, when King Tiridates III was converted by St Gregory the Illuminator. That was more than a decade before Constantine’s Edict of Milan. The Armenian Apostolic Church traces its origins to the apostles Thaddeus and Bartholomew.

The Orthodox Church, for its part, considers itself to be the one true Church. When fourteen Orthodox churches planned their Holy and Great Council in Crete in 2016, its documents stated that the Orthodox Church is “the One, Holy, Catholic and Apostolic Church”. Catholics and Orthodox each believe that the other has departed in some respects from the fullness of the apostolic faith. The Catholic Church recognises the apostolic succession and sacraments of the Orthodox Churches (Unitatis Redintegratio 15); Orthodox views of Catholic sacraments vary. The most accurate answer, then, is this: both trace an unbroken line back to the apostles and were in communion with each other for the first thousand years, and each believes it is the continuation of the one Church Christ founded. Catholic teaching is that the Church of Christ subsists in the Catholic Church, governed by the successor of Peter and the bishops in communion with him, and that the Orthodox Churches are true Churches with valid sacraments, though not in full communion with it (Lumen Gentium 8; Dominus Iesus 17).

7. “The early Church was simple”

A serious objection, made by many Protestants and secular historians, is that the early Church was simple, a fellowship of believers with little structure, and that Catholicism is a much later development that buried the original.

Catholics agree that the Church grew and developed. Jesus himself predicted it. He compared the kingdom of heaven to a grain of mustard seed, “which is the least indeed of all seeds; but when it is grown up, it is greater than all herbs, and becometh a tree, so that the birds of the air come, and dwell in the branches thereof” (Matthew 13:31-32). An oak tree looks very different from an acorn, but it is the same living thing.

Catholic historians are honest about how gradual some developments were. Eamon Duffy, a leading Catholic historian at Cambridge, writes in his history of the papacy Saints and Sinners (1997) that the early Roman church was probably led by a group of presbyters or elders, and that a single presiding bishop clearly emerges in Rome only in the second century. Catholics see no threat in this: the role of Peter’s successor could take time to take its later form without being a later invention.

Some critics have offered an alternative history. In 1931 a booklet by the Baptist pastor J. M. Carroll, The Trail of Blood, was published shortly after his death, claiming that a line of “true” Baptist-like churches had existed outside Catholicism ever since the apostles, persecuted by Rome through the centuries. The booklet sold millions of copies. But most Baptist historians today reject its theory, because the groups it names had very different beliefs from each other and from Baptists, and there is no evidence of any continuous line.

8. A Church of sinners

The history of the Catholic Church includes grave sins by its members and leaders, some of them shocking. Catholics do not deny this. They believe that such sins wound the Church without destroying what Christ founded.

The pattern begins with the Twelve themselves. Jesus chose Judas Iscariot, who betrayed him for thirty pieces of silver, and Peter, who three times denied knowing him on the night of his arrest (Luke 22:47-62). If the first leaders of the Church included a traitor and a coward, no one should be surprised that their successors have included sinners.

Some of the Church’s darkest moments came in the ninth and tenth centuries, when the papacy became a prize fought over by Roman aristocratic families. In 897 Pope Stephen VI had the corpse of his predecessor, Pope Formosus, dug up, dressed in papal vestments, propped on a throne and put on trial for crimes. The dead pope was found guilty, three fingers of his blessing hand were cut off, and his body was thrown into the Tiber. The “Cadaver Synod” provoked such outrage that Stephen was soon imprisoned and strangled.

Christians have argued for centuries about whether such sins mean the Church has lost its claim to be Christ’s Church. In the early fifth century, St Augustine debated with the Donatists, a North African group who held that the Church must be a pure community of saints, and that sacraments given by sinful clergy were invalid. At a great conference at Carthage in 411, Augustine argued that the Church on earth is a mixed body, like the field in Jesus’s parable where wheat and weeds grow together until the harvest (Matthew 13:24-30). Only at the end will God separate them. Catholics still hold this view: the Church is holy because Christ is holy, not because its members always are.

9. What all Christians received through this Church

Whatever one’s view of the Catholic Church today, it is a fact that much that all Christians rely on came down through it: the creeds, the great councils, and the list of books in the New Testament.

The pattern for the councils is found in the New Testament itself. When a dispute arose over whether Gentile converts needed to be circumcised and keep the Law of Moses, “the apostles and ancients assembled to consider of this matter”, debated, and sent a letter announcing their decision (Acts 15:1-29). Every later council followed that pattern.

Christians did not have a fixed list of New Testament books from the beginning. Different churches used slightly different collections for centuries. In 367 St Athanasius, bishop of Alexandria, wrote his annual Easter letter to the churches of Egypt. In it he listed the twenty-seven books of the New Testament exactly as almost all Christians have them today, the first known list to do so (Festal Letter 39). Councils in North Africa confirmed the same list in the 390s.

The Bible itself was preserved for centuries by monks copying it by hand. At the twin monastery of Wearmouth-Jarrow in northern England, where St Bede the Venerable lived, the monks produced three huge complete Latin Bibles. One of them, the Codex Amiatinus, was carried by Abbot Ceolfrith as a gift for the Pope when he set out for Rome in 716. It weighs about 34 kilograms, and today, in Florence, it is the oldest surviving complete Latin Bible in the world.

10. Test it for yourself

The best way to settle where the Church came from is to read the earliest Christian writers for yourself and see what kind of Church they describe. Their writings are easily available online and in inexpensive translations.

The New Testament itself recommends reading with a guide. When Philip the deacon met an Ethiopian court official reading the prophet Isaiah in his chariot, he asked whether he understood what he was reading. The Ethiopian replied, “And how can I, unless some man shew me?” Philip explained the passage, and the official asked to be baptised that very day (Acts 8:26-39).

The earliest writers give a living link back to the apostles. In old age, St Irenaeus wrote to a former friend, Florinus, who had drifted into heresy. He reminded him that as a boy in Smyrna he had sat and listened to the aged bishop St Polycarp, who used to describe his conversations with the apostle John and others who had seen the Lord. Irenaeus said he could still remember where Polycarp sat, how he walked and what he looked like (Eusebius, Church History 5.20). From John to Polycarp to Irenaeus: a chain of three lifetimes back to Jesus.

Many people who have followed this path have become Catholic. In 1922, G. K. Chesterton, the famous English writer, journalist and creator of the detective Father Brown, was received into the Catholic Church after years as an Anglican. In The Catholic Church and Conversion (1926) he explained that the Church had been, for him, the one institution that had lasted through the centuries without being swallowed by any of the fashions it outlived. You do not have to agree with him to find the question worth exploring.

Frequently asked questions

Did Constantine create the Catholic Church? No. The Church had bishops, the Eucharist and the name “Catholic” for two centuries before Constantine legalised Christianity in 313.

When did the Catholic Church begin? Catholics date it to Jesus’s ministry and to Pentecost, around AD 30-33.

Is the Orthodox Church older than the Catholic Church? Both Catholics and Orthodox trace their origins to the apostles and were one Church for a thousand years. Each regards itself as the continuation of the original Church.

Who was the first pope? Catholics regard St Peter as the first Bishop of Rome. See Why Did Jesus Call Peter a Rock?

You may also like Are Catholics Christian? and What Leads Adults to Become Catholic?

Sources and further reading

  • The Bible: Mark 3:13-19; Matthew 13:24-32; 28:18-20; Luke 22:47-62; John 21:15-17; Acts 1:15-26; 2:1-47; 8:26-39; 11:19-26; 15:1-29; Titus 1:5; 2 Timothy 2:2; 1 Peter 5:13.
  • Second Vatican Council, Lumen Gentium (1964), 8.
  • The Didache; 1 Clement 42-44; St Ignatius of Antioch, Letters; St Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.3; Eusebius, Church History 2.25 and 5.20.
  • Acts of the Martyrs of Abitinae (304).
  • St Athanasius, Festal Letter 39 (367).
  • Holy and Great Council of the Orthodox Church (Crete, 2016), “Relations of the Orthodox Church with the Rest of the Christian World” and the Encyclical.
  • Eamon Duffy, Saints and Sinners: A History of the Popes (1997; 4th edition 2014).
  • J. M. Carroll, The Trail of Blood (1931).
  • G. K. Chesterton, The Catholic Church and Conversion (1926).

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *